REVIEWER'S GUIDE

Substantive Review of the Article
Your review should evaluate the material based on standard article components. If the content deviates significantly, please provide your comments.

Title: The title must adequately, clearly, and precisely describe the subject of the manuscript, without being open to multiple interpretations. Please suggest an alternative title if necessary.
Abstract: The abstract should briefly state the research objective, the methods employed, the results, and the core conclusions. Please keep in mind that the abstract is the most widely read part of any paper.
Literature Review: Authors must acknowledge the contributions of others relevant to the article through citations. Citations in the introduction should demonstrate the innovation and/or novelty introduced by the authors, supported by a gap analysis. Citations should not be excessive.
Objectives: The objectives of the study must be clearly articulated and should address the research hypotheses.
Methods: The methods used to achieve the objectives must be described precisely and in sufficient detail to allow a competent reader to replicate the work. Tools, materials, hardware/software platforms, and frameworks used in the research should also be specified.
Clarity: Authors should present information regarding the methodology and research results in a simple, concise, and effective manner, ensuring the text is easily understood by readers.
Organization: The manuscript should develop and explain the research subject in a logical and effective manner.
Duplication: The manuscript should not repeat descriptions of work already published by the authors or others. Consider whether the manuscript could be condensed—without losing content—by combining two or more tables or figures. Reviewers may provide comments if any duplication is identified within the text.
Calculations: Where appropriate, reviewers should attempt to verify the calculations performed by the authors (by checking a few randomly selected instances).
Alignment between Text, Tables, and Figures: All tables and figures must be referenced within the text. Statements made in the text must be consistent with the content presented in the tables and figures. Table and Figure Titles: Titles must accurately reflect the content. Please provide suggestions to improve the quality of table/figure titles.
Table Headings/Captions: Interpretations must be clear and precise, and must use the correct SI units.
Graphs: Data used for graphs/figures must be accurate.
Conclusions: Conclusions must adequately and clearly address the hypothesis and be supported by data and analysis.
Speculation: Authors must clearly distinguish between speculation and fact.
References: All citations in the manuscript must be included in the bibliography. A minimum of 10 references is required, 60% of which must be primary sources (scientific journals, conference proceedings, reference books, or academic theses/dissertations) published within the last 5 (five) years.
Reviewers are expected to use proper and correct Indonesian.

Submitting Review Results

Once you have agreed to conduct a review, you may download the article file and any supplementary files. You may complete the review form, provide comments, or upload a file containing your assessment for the editor and/or the author(s). You are expected to provide a recommendation regarding the quality of the article. The review must be completed within 4 weeks. If you require more time, please inform the Editor (lppm@unan.ac.id).